Africa and More
How Salty is the “Salt of the Earth?”
“You are the salt of the earth, but if salt has lost its taste, how shall its saltiness be restored?
It is no longer good for anything except to be thrown out and trampled under people's feet.” (Matthew 5:13)
The Role of Confessional Institutions and Traditional Customs of Faith in Preserving Religious Life
I. Introduction
At the end of April, 2007 I traveled with two other Presbyterian pastors to African Bible College (ABC) in
Palmer Robertson, the Vice Chancellor of ABC Uganda, is fond of saying that this is
While we were there we heard the unwanted loudspeakers at 5:30 am every morning calling everyone to the Muslim morning prayers. But the biggest challenges to biblical faithfulness are not primarily coming from the Muslim minority or from others outside the ranks of professing Christians. The challenges are especially inside the church, where large numbers of people are professing to respond to the call of Christ. Hundreds of thousands gather to hear heretical American “preachers” tell them how to get rich and be healed. Everyone expects corruption in all spheres of life and society, though so many claim to be born again. In this kind of environment, though the revival be ever so genuine and widely felt, it is hard to believe that more than a very small percentage of the church will have anything to pass on to the next generation.
On the way back to
This shocked me. The normal way of life in this man’s village is an amazing story of success in passing on the faith to the next generation – one that we never hear about. On our home turf of
It is the purpose of this paper to consider the connection between unusual times of heightened localized spiritual interest, and the formation of institutions and customs of worship and religious instruction. What are the conclusions that might be drawn from Scripture and history for Christian churches and schools today in
II. Life in
Dean Anderson, a native of
My village is Katwijk, 40,000 residents, most of whom are at least a member of a church (and 95 % of churches are one or other Reformed flavour). The largest church is the Hervormde Kerk (formally the state church), approx. 22,000 members spread over 10 buildings. The GKN (Gereformeerde Kerk – synodical, cf. CRC in
The Reformed churches (majority) give regular catechism from 12 years to about 20 when, normally, young people would do profession of faith. They sing mostly psalms, some virtually exclusively, and mostly in the old fashioned way (quite slowly, without rhythm).
The mayor of the village also has a theological education, is conservative Reformed and has a preaching license for the Hervormde Kerk. The local council pays for the Reformed youth work of the Hervormde Kerk in the village! (Church and state?)
Indeed, you see here God’s blessings on faithful covenantal village life. Although, the number and variety of churches also show the result of sin (not that secession is necessarily sin, but it arises because of sin). My personal preference would be for the village churches to unite, but this is only feasible if they give up their national ties to denominations. That is not going to happen. And it is in the national ties to sometimes liberal denominations (even if the village churches are conservative) that means that I, for example, could never be comfortable in the Hervormde kerk.
One important factor in Reformed churches is also of course a strong eldership, but you knew that!
Our lengthy layover in
(As a side point, the question of an economically sustainable model of discipleship/Christian education for village life in
I first presented some thoughts on these issues in Adult Sunday School in our Presbyterian church in
I do not wish to present an incorrect account of the struggles of the Dutch people to hold on to orthodox Christianity as if to suggest that this has been an easy thing to do. A 19th century essay written by Abraham Kuyper, a Prime Minister and founder of a Protestant University makes it clear that keeping the faith in the churches and schools required great diligence. Writing about those who had abandoned the historical confessions of faith (theological/political “Liberals” in his terminology), Kuyper wrote:
This is what they proposed: (1) all clergy were to be educated at state universities; (2) the professors would mainly be recruited among Liberals; (3) synodical administration was to be completely in Liberal hands; and (4) the regulations of the church were to be gradually transformed into a set of rules governing an ethical-religious association without a common Confession. (Bratt, 249)
Kuyper also noted the interest that those who favored a break with Dutch religious tradition had in controlling schools:
To a certain extent the same can be said about education. The Liberals were also unwilling to respect the independence of the School. On the contrary, it was to be a tool and its staff a recruiting-cadre for elections. (Bratt, 250)
While I have not studied these matters and am not pretending to understand the political and religious struggles of 19th century
It would be incorrect to think that the Dutch tradition was one of intolerance. Kuyper’s desire for true freedom is reflected in the earlier Dutch tradition that some scholars contend had a significant impact on none other than the Pilgrims who settled on
The 11 years the Pilgrims spent in
The Pilgrims left Leyden in 1620; William Bradford described their departure in a now-famous passage which later gave the Pilgrims their name: “So they left that goodly and pleasant city which had been their resting place near twelve years; but they knew they were pilgrims, and looked not much on those things, but lift up their eyes to the heavens, their dearest country, and quieted their spirits.” [William Bradford, Of
http://www.fee.org/publications/the-freeman/article.asp?aid=1575 : The Freeman: Ideas on
By Robert A. Peterson
The tolerance that was apparently part of Dutch life is important for our purposes. The tradition in Katwijk was not maintained primarily by the force of the state, but by some other power that we are seeking to explore. Kuyper rejects the idea of state coercion in establishing a religious hegemony. He sees this as an abuse of state power, fundamentally antitheitical to his notion of “sphere sovereignty.” For Kuyper, the rule of Jesus the Messiah as King of Kings is mediated through human beings and is not wholly entrusted to any one “sphere” of society. He critiques the “Caesarism” of the all-powerful state, considering that to be an evil alternative to a true tolerance and liberty that would allow churches and schools to be something other than the tool of political power. Kuyper insisted that God was sovereign over all, but that the delegation of that sovereignty proceeded not entirely to a single ruler or entity, but was divided among more than one sphere.
But here is the glorious principle of Freedom! This perfect Sovereignty of the sinless Messiah at the same time directly denies and challenges all absolute Sovereignty among sinful men on earth, and does so by dividing life into separate spheres, each with its own sovereignty.
Jesus said in the Sermon on the Mount that His disciples were “the salt of the earth.” Salt has a preservative role. But when salt loses its flavor, it is no good for anything, accept to be thrown out. The imagery He used suggests a world that is in a state of decay, but people of faith who are a part of a new resurrection world are to be different from the world around them, and thus slow the decay of the earth. In some historical situations, despite remarkable beginnings, the salt of Christian witness in a movement or community has quickly lost its savor. In others, such as in the
The Separatist “Pilgrims” left Leyden in 1620 for northern “
In the last quarter of the 20th century the typically Dutch system of pillarization eroded and has almost disappeared now, but contrary to that general tendency the experiential reformed pillar has grown and is relatively stable. The core of that pillar is in many ways formed by the Reformed Congregations.
By founding their own organisations and institutions the members of the Reformed Congregations and other reformed people who were congenial with them, isolated themselves not only from the secular world, but also from liberal Christian institutions. Of course that isolation is not absolute, but on several fields that were directly related to their belief system. In that way they created a social sphere of their own, that helped to sustain (especially for young people) the plausibility of the experiential reformed doctrines and life style.
The total group of experiential reformed people in the
Especially in the last decades Dutch society became more and more secular. That makes a great difference from the period before 1960 when the religious parties had a majority in the Parliament and Christian schools, newspapers, trade unions and several other organisations on a religious basis had an important place in society.
At the moment influential groups in society and in politics not only see orthodox religion as something outdated, but also as dangerous for the security and the welfare of a liberal society.
They primarily look at Muslim fundamentalists, but they also criticise the conservative protestants, especially those in experientially reformed circles. They promote a heavier control of religious schools and put up for debate the government subsidies for that kind of education. The SGP already lost a large amount of the government subsidies for political parties. This also happens to the youth organisation of the Reformed Congregations (and other churches).
As a result of this development, members of the Reformed Congregations and other congenial groups feel themselves as an isolated and uncomprehended minority, only tolerated in the margins of modern society. But not only in society the position of the Reformed Congregations is an isolated one. The same can be said about their position in the ecclesiastical spectrum. They don’t participate in any national or international ecumenical organisation. (“How to Cope with Modernity?” Chris Janse)
The on-line source Wikipedia cites the following demographics:
According to the CIA World Factbook,[1] as of 2002 the religious makeup of the
Whatever else can be said of the struggles of the remaining reformed minority in Dutch villages like Katwijk, one cannot help but be impressed with the doctrinal, sacramental, and ethical continuity that allows a minority community to live as a full participant in modernity while maintaining vital religious traditions of Christian continuity. Here we do not have an Amish-like rejection of modern life, but a confessional and behavioral life that makes historic Christian faith and morals plausible to each new generation of young Christians.
III. Confessional Christianity
Much of modern Christianity is almost entirely experiential. The Dutch tradition did not reject the vitality of Christian spiritual experience, but along with other reformed groups insisted that the experience of Christianity needed to be governed by confessional statements that were designed to function under the authority of Scripture. These were not replacements for the Bible, but systematic summarizations of the Bible, useful for doctrinal clarity and especially for teaching. In the Dutch tradition, the written confessional documents of the church are called the “three forms of unity” which are the Belgic Confession (1561), the Canons of Dort (1619), and the Heidelberg Catechism (1563).
For our purposes the Heidelberg Catechism is the most significant. This document has been of great importance to the week in and week out life of worship and instruction in reformed homes, schools, and churches. Organized into 52 sections, the catechism was read through in its entirety every year. The person who faithfully attended worship every week would gain a strong familiarity with the unifying Christian doctrines within the larger covenant community. The question and answer format was very useful for memorization, family discipleship, and church instruction for those who were preparing to publicly profess their faith in order to be admitted to the Lord’s Table.
This final matter was a major part of the Dutch Reformed life. The doctrines of the faith were thoroughly taught and considered over a number of years before someone took his place among the number of adult professors who communed at the Lord’s Table. Admission to this sacrament was not precisely tied to the proof of saving faith but to the willingness, knowledge, and capability of taking on the adult responsibilities of that profession of faith. Having a vital confessional core tied to the congregational Christian experience of worship and instruction, particularly when linked to the admission to the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper, is a powerful tool in keeping the content of faith before the community of believers as a normal part of the life of faith. Without a strong confessional component to Christian experience, a movement of vital Christian life can quickly give way to a new generation of spiritual decline where the pillars of doctrine-based Christianity are not so much explicitly rejected as simply forgotten or ignored.
IV. Seasons of Revival
This is not to suggest that experience is unimportant. Throughout history seasons of religious revival have had surprising impacts on many lives. In Acts 2 we read of an amazing openness to the message of Christ that came from the work of the Spirit of God.
Revival is testified to not only in biblical accounts, but in the pages of history. Christian and non-Christian observers alike are forced by the data to admit that something extraordinary took place in
In our day, we read credible accounts of revival not so much in Western countries, but in many other places around the globe that have been enjoying a special moment of Christian interest and enthusiasm. One such place is
September 1929 was an all-time 'low' for Dr Joe Church, missionary in the tiny East African state of
Joe Church stayed with friends on Namirembe Hill and on the Sunday morning walked up to the cathedral. Outside it was an African standing by his motor-bike. His name was Simeoni Nsibambi.
'There is something missing in me and the
The two men spent two days studying the Bible and praying together. In a subsequent letter home, Joe wrote. There can be nothing to stop a real outpouring of the Holy Spirit in
The East African Revival had started. From
This kind of revival cannot be manufactured by man, but is presented in the Bible as the work of God, who alone gives such extraordinary growth (1 Corinthians 3:7).
V. Institutions and Customs of Reformation
What is to be our response to such a movement of God? Is there some standard of belief and life that the Christian church is to be rooted in, thereby being continually “re-formed” back to a given pattern, even after extraordinary times of enthusiasm may fade? This is what is implied by the word “reformation” in the heading above. Is the church to be an evolved and forever evolving entity, or is it to have a given core that it must continually come back to, thereby making it reformed and ever reforming?
If we return to the example of unusual growth in
It is very clear that Paul was urging upon these church leaders that they continue in the doctrines and the ministerial example that they had been taught by him and had observed in Him. He does not suggest any possibility that they would avoid troubles from outside the churches and even from within their own number. In fact he assures them of the opposite – they will face trials. In the expectation of dangerous and challenging days ahead he commends them to a stable God and to his unchanging word of grace. He encourages them to stick with the pattern of life and biblical teaching that they have seen and received.
In First Timothy we hear of troubles in
The churches in Ephesus needed to be firmly established in God’s Word and leaders who held to approved doctrine were to be identified, trained, and installed with the manifest approval of the church (I Tim. 3:1-7). Teaching the followers of Christ was seen as the essential way of continuity for the churches, and that teaching was measured against some fixed deposit of “sound words” (1 Tim. 6:3) in accord with standards of godliness that had been received.
Confessions of faith are nothing more than approved understandings of “sound words” by which all teaching and behavior is tested. If individuals teaching and living against such standards are not to be countenanced, certainly institutions and customs that are corrosive to the deposit of biblical faith and practice would not be permitted to have free reign in the important task of Christian discipleship (Matthew 28:19). The Apostle writes to the Ephesian churches directly urging them not to be tossed about “by every wind of doctrine” (Eph. 4:14) and making sure that fathers in every church household understand the obligation that they have to bring up their children “in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.” By now we should have a good sense that this body of truth that is used for the Christian nurture of the young is not thought by Paul to be an evolving and variable matter of choice, but is some fixed content of gospel doctrine and life that is to be known and passed on as it has been received.
This must involve all the tools that the church has been given for the fulfillment of this ministry including sacramental practices, formal and informal systems of instruction and worship, and systems of leadership in families and throughout the entire body of believers. The expectation is that everyone will “grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ” (Eph. 4:15) and that this will happen from speaking and living the truth in love within Christian community. As stable biblical truths and approved practices of worship and life are passed on from generation to generation, institutions are defined and customs of family and church life become rooted in the practice of a people who claim to be ruled by the Word of God. This work of continual reformation seems to be the Bible plan to keep the church true to her Savior and Lord.
VI. Revival and Reformation
Now that we have briefly explored both revival and reformation, we can consider the logical possibilities of the absence or presence of either or both of these things. First, what if there is revival but no reformation? What can we expect when there is a time of unusual Christian gospel interest and openness (revival) without institutional investment and customs of worship and life in accord with a fixed revealed truth (reformation)? Without the institutions and customs that define a certain type of life as normal, we can only expect that challenges to biblical truths and behavior will begin to take hold, perhaps very quickly, within the life of a faith community. Much of the earlier life of faith will soon be forgotten.
What if we see significant efforts of reformation at a time when there are no remaining signs of revival? It is easy to see that vigorous efforts at the establishment of new biblical patterns will appear very odd to the prevailing culture of the church, since she has already been so thoroughly conformed to the patterns of the world around her (Romans 12:1-2) without perhaps having any recognition of her poor spiritual condition. Some faithful churches and schools may be established as a remaining witness to the world around them, but without a major move of God’s Spirit, there is little reason to think that people will be willing to redefine cherished assumptions of identity, belief, and behavior that would allow them to embrace new ways of life that seem strange even to the remaining Christian community in such a place.
In the third place, we can easily dismiss the no revival, no reformation option. Here is a community and church at peace in its own worldliness, without even the thorn of small efforts of biblical faithfulness suggesting another way.
The final logical alternative is the combination of a time of revival coinciding with or immediately followed by solid works of reformation before the effects of revival have completely evaporated. Here we have an opportunity for a Christian community that can be distinctive for centuries with a saltiness that will not quickly lose its savor, as we considered in the case of the little
VII. Conclusion
In
What about the world of
<< Home